
Originally Posted by
TheGuru
‘85Knight has been beating this drum for years. It’s not as cut and dry as ’85 Knight saying that the City’s Big 5 (City, Dunbar, EW, Patterson & Poly) were better than the MIAA Big 5 (CHC, Gilman, Loyola, McDonogh & Mt. St. Joseph) in “2 out of 4 years and a toss up in Tavon’s junior year.
If we look at 2005, the city Div. 1 big boys had an avg Max Prep ranking of 84th in the state. Dunbar was the highest at 46th and EW was 121st. Dunbar was beaten by Loyola and EW was shutout by Linganore in the regular season. City lost to Westminster, Dunbar to Snow Hill & Patterson lost to Perry Hall, all in the state playoffs and none of which were powerhouse teams.
In 2005, the MIAA (minus Georgetown Prep) had an avg Max Preps ranking of 18th in the state. Gilman finished #1 in the state and Mt. St. Joseph was the lowest at 47th. Gilman beat DeMatha, Loyola beat Dunbar and a mediocre CHC team took Friendly to the limit down in PG County before losing by 3 in a shootout. ADVANTAGE: MIAA
In 2006, Dunbar & EW won state championships and finished #17 & #4 (Max Preps) respectively. Dunbar lost to Loyola again and City finished #23 but lost to a putrid Franklin team on a 50 yard run and extra point against a supposedly all-time great City College defense. The avg ranking that year was 44 for the City’s Big 5. Poly (#79) & Patterson (#99) brought up the rear for the city.
The MIAA had an avg ranking of 36th in the state in 2006. Gilman was 16th, Loyola 10th & McDonogh 21st. Calvert Hall (92nd) brought the avg ranking way down. NO ADVANTAGE: TIE
2007 saw the city league fall back a bit in the state rankings. City (#62), Dunbar (#6-State Champs), EW (#55), Patterson (#135) & Poly (#43) had an avg of 50th in the state. In the state playoffs, City lost to EW, EW was blown out by Friendly by over 6 TDS in the regular season (although forfeited by Friendly) and by Eastern Tech (ET) in the playoffs. Patterson lost to Parkville 48-0 in week 1 and Poly lost to ET in the playoffs, too.
The MIAA had a good year in 2007 with an avg ranking of 23rd in the state. CHC was 51st, Gilman- 22nd, Loyola- 8th, McDonogh- 20th & Mt. St Joseph- 14th. CHC was beginning to rebuild and knocked Randallstown out of the state playoffs and got beat by a good ET team by a score of 15-6. ADVANTAGE: MIAA
Tavon’s final season, 2008, saw the city schools fall back slightly to an avg of 54th in the state. City was 60th, Dunbar- 9th (State Champs), EW- 43rd, Patterson-101st & Poly -58th. City lost to Fort Hill in week #1, Dunbar lost to a strong Gwynn Park team, EW beat Friendly but lost to Loyola in the regular season & ET in the playoffs and Poly lost to Gilman and ET.
In 2008, the MIAA had an avg of 26th in Maryland. CHC-54th, Gilman-19th, Loyola-3rd, McDonogh- 39th and Mt. St. Joe-15th. Again, CHC lost to ET by 1 pt on a missed FG late in the game, Gilman beat DeMatha & Poly and St. Joe beat Thomas Johnson but lost to Allegany. ADVANTAGE: MIAA
While the City schools feasted on the likes of Walbrook, DuBois, Lake Clifton, Douglass, Carver, Mervo and Digital Harbor, the MIAA was playing Georgetown Prep, DeMatha, Good Counsel, Friendly, St. Joseph’s Prep (PA), Keyser (WV), Bergen Catholic (NJ), Eastern Tech, Gonzaga, Thomas Johnson & Allegany. Tougher schedules and higher rankings led to a 3-0-1 MIAA advantage over the City’s Big 5 during the Tavon Austin years. It seems to me that ‘85Knight was drinking spiked Kool-Aid when he posted that nonsense.
Btw, I've been on record as stating that the 2006 Red Storm with Raytron Leak was one of the most physically dominant teams I have ever seen in MD and the 2007 Poets would have also won state championships at the 2A, 3A & 4A classifications & the MIAA.
As for the agent provocateur, First Down, and GA, I'd rather see my HS play the best that MD has to offer from the public and private ranks as well as 1 or 2 out of state teams. Dunbar is one of the best, year in & year out, in MD regardless of classification. And this is coming from a Dunbar "hater".