Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Spot72

FACTS on WHO really receives FOOD STAMPS

8 posts in this topic

"Who Gets Food Stamps?

 

The most recent Department of Agriculture report on the general characteristics of the SNAP program’s beneficiaries says that in the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, 2010:

 

47 percent of beneficiaries were children under age 18.

8 percent were age 60 or older.

41 percent lived in a household with earnings from a job — the so-called “working poor.”

The average household received a monthly benefit of $287.

36 percent were white (non-Hispanic), 22 percent were African American (non-Hispanic) and 10 percent were Hispanic (Table A.21).

 

Update, Feb. 5: USDA data understate these figures, however, because participants are not required to state their race or ethnic background. As a result, 18.9 percent are listed as “race unknown.”) A more accurate estimate of the racial and ethnic composition of food-stamp recipients can be drawn from U.S. Census data, based on a sample of households surveyed each year in the American Community Survey. For 2010, Census data show the following for households that reported getting food stamp assistance during the year:

 

49 percent were white (non-Hispanic); 26 percent were black or African American; and 20 percent were Hispanic (of any race)."

 

http://www.factcheck.org/2012/01/newts-faulty-food-stamp-claim/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
"Who Gets Food Stamps?

 

The most recent Department of Agriculture report on the general characteristics of the SNAP program’s beneficiaries says that in the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, 2010:

 

47 percent of beneficiaries were children under age 18.

8 percent were age 60 or older.

41 percent lived in a household with earnings from a job — the so-called “working poor.”

The average household received a monthly benefit of $287.

36 percent were white (non-Hispanic), 22 percent were African American (non-Hispanic) and 10 percent were Hispanic (Table A.21).

 

Update, Feb. 5: USDA data understate these figures, however, because participants are not required to state their race or ethnic background. As a result, 18.9 percent are listed as “race unknown.”) A more accurate estimate of the racial and ethnic composition of food-stamp recipients can be drawn from U.S. Census data, based on a sample of households surveyed each year in the American Community Survey. For 2010, Census data show the following for households that reported getting food stamp assistance during the year:

 

49 percent were white (non-Hispanic); 26 percent were black or African American; and 20 percent were Hispanic (of any race)."

 

http://www.factcheck.org/2012/01/newts-faulty-food-stamp-claim/

 

Who exactly falls under the category of "white"? For example, all Middle Eastern Americans check the "white" box or "other" so it's unclear just who is "white" and who is not.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
"Who Gets Food Stamps?

 

The most recent Department of Agriculture report on the general characteristics of the SNAP program’s beneficiaries says that in the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, 2010:

 

47 percent of beneficiaries were children under age 18.

8 percent were age 60 or older.

41 percent lived in a household with earnings from a job — the so-called “working poor.”

The average household received a monthly benefit of $287.

36 percent were white (non-Hispanic), 22 percent were African American (non-Hispanic) and 10 percent were Hispanic (Table A.21).

 

Update, Feb. 5: USDA data understate these figures, however, because participants are not required to state their race or ethnic background. As a result, 18.9 percent are listed as “race unknown.”) A more accurate estimate of the racial and ethnic composition of food-stamp recipients can be drawn from U.S. Census data, based on a sample of households surveyed each year in the American Community Survey. For 2010, Census data show the following for households that reported getting food stamp assistance during the year:

 

49 percent were white (non-Hispanic); 26 percent were black or African American; and 20 percent were Hispanic (of any race)."

http://www.factcheck.org/2012/01/newts-faulty-food-stamp-claim/

 

Ah, gotta love numbers. I have no axe to grind as a moderate (really, I am a moderate!), but I am always suspicious of folks touting numbers in an effort to make a point. Unless they haul out ALL the numbers, which is rarely done.

 

Look above at the percentages in bold, but then compare it to the demographic make-up of the population. One would assume that all things being equal, the relative proportion of our US population mirrors the above. It does not.

 

2011 population demographics:

 

 

  • White non Hispanic - 63.4%
  • Black - 13.1%
  • Hispanic - 16.7%

Source: US Census Bureau

 

 

So... it is clear that there is a large disproportion of Blacks (almost twice as likely) and Hispanics (20% more likely) having to take advantage or relief from assistance than do Whites (23% less likely) per capita, if you are segmenting by race. Essentially another set of numbers that seriously mitigates whatever point you might be trying to make. Neither answer WHO really recieves food stamps in a meaningful way, or more importantly, help explain the demographic disparity or why they find themselves in such dire straits to require this assistance, for which I am glad exists as I would never want to see a fellow American citizen going hungry in this day and age.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Who exactly falls under the category of "white"? For example, all Middle Eastern Americans check the "white" box or "other" so it's unclear just who is "white" and who is not.

 

Talk to the Department of Agriculture.:D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Spot72 appears to be the new race baiter.

 

I think this is a response to that other thread about Obama winning because of people who want free stuff. I think I'll sit this one out though. I've seen this movie before and I know how it ends already

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I think this is a response to that other thread about Obama winning because of people who want free stuff. I think I'll sit this one out though. I've seen this movie before and I know how it ends already

 

Could be, just seems to be a general tone to all of the threads that he/she starts.

 

I think this movie has many sequels.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites